"Post Under Moderation" and icons missing after template change - cleared cache, no known overrides

I am testing a swap from one YooTheme template to another. The icons have disappeared and the "post under moderation" message has reappeared. I have tried these things:
Cleared the browser, Joomla and EasySocial cache
Changed the EasySocial Template (has no effect on anything)
Compiled LESS in the template
Looked for com_easysocial in the template files anywhere

I don't know what else to try, nothing I do seems to change anything. I think there is a style override somewhere, but I can't find one, or any reference to one in this template.