Pagination Issues. Clicking a Page Does Not Goto that Page

Hello,

I've been having a few issues with Pagination. I've noticed that when clicking on a page to navigate to in the bottom navigation, Easyblog decides to redirect to another page. Say for instance, I click page 4, it'll take me to page 9 though the url looks right /latest/page-4.html

It doesn't matter if I click a page number or the "Next" or "Previous" button. Same issue.

I had a similar issue once and it was sh404sef related, then it would allow me to navigate so many pages ahead before it reset to a few pages back and I couldn't progress any further.

I fixed that issue by purging my URL's in sh404sef's url manager (minus custom urls, aliases and pageids).

I may be able to fix this one with the same method but it'll just pop up again at some point. I made this screencast showing exactly what I mean:
http://screencast-o-matic.com/watch/c2Qlh9nSlU

Any ideas on how to solve this once and for all?

Please notify me of any changes made and don't clear my urls before asking me, if that's needed. I have hundreds of custom urls that I created to match the format of my old site before using Joomla.