Cannot view group members

When I create a new group category and create groups in that category, I get an error message if I try to view the group members. However, when I create a new group under an existing (old) category, I can view the members without any problems.

To make sure it wasn't a category settings issue, I saved an existing old category and changed the name.

The error message is COM_EASYSOCIAL_GROUP_DOES_NOT_HAVE_ACCESS
I get this message even if I use the super admin login.

This section can only be seen by users with a valid subscription.
If you have a valid subscription, please login now

Support is
Online

The support team is online and will be able to answer your inquiries. Please stay calm, follow the rules and do not cross post.

We will attend to you as soon as we can.

Your time
Stack Ideas time