Hi Jason,
Firstly, seems like there is a few template override for toolbar for those easyblog and easydiscuss where it shows as per your screenshot, where if I try to rename the template override for the toolbar it shows fine. You should reconfigure back your template override so that the styling was not broken. or if you want to use the default easyblog/easydiscuss's toolbar you should just rename the file
Do you change your template to use Elegant currently? if yes, you should not encounter the toolbar issue anymore as the template override for the toolbar is for the riskoracle's template
By the way, we actually got toolbar module for each component (easysocial,easyblog and easydiscuss) if you want to put it on other page (eg:homepage)