Hi Shaun Erickson,

May I know exactly how to replicate this? is it you are using 3rd party extension to add new subscriber in your site?
And Is it possible for you to provide us with the back end and FTP access to your site to check on this issue?

You can add the information needed by edit your first post in the Details section or you can just include your site's access once at http://stackideas.com/dashboard/site rather than needing to keep adding them in your replies