hey Zack,
I am sorry for the delay of this reply,
I've checked in your site, it seems like you assign that search module on your site position-top is Easyblog, I already help you changed to use Easysocial search module, it should display correctly now.
By the way, I noticed when I login in your then I hitting this error, may i know did you update Wanderers latest version yet?
Fatal error: Class 'modEasyBlogMostPopularPostHelper' not found in JoomlaFolder/templates/wanderers/html/mod_easyblogmostpopularpost/default.php on line 28
To temporary fix this, you can rename this file to
JoomlaFolder/templates/wanderers/html/mod_easyblogmostpopularpost/default.php to JoomlaFolder/templates/wanderers/html/mod_easyblogmostpopularpost/default.php_bak
Hope this help.