Email notification for second admin

Hey guys,

I have an issue with the email notifications - on our website we are two admins, and the second admin does not receive an email notification when someone opens a new discussion in EasyDiscuss. Here are some more details:

1. We have two admin accounts:
"admin1" - this is the default admin account, that was created when we installed the website (Joomla).
"admin2" - we added this admin account (Super User) later.

So, only "admin1" receives notifications when somebody posts in EasyDiscuss.

2. I'm attaching a screenshot with the "Notifications" settings

So, how can I make it so both admins receive an email notification when somebody posts in EasyDiscuss?

P.S. It doesn't matter for the above issue, but yes, we have a Cron job configured properly (otherwise even the first admin would not receive emails.)